top of page

Editor's View: Brexit's Broken Promises: The Elusive Green Dream

In the wake of Brexit, the UK's agricultural sector stood on the cusp of a transformative era, one that promised greener pastures and a sustainable future. However, as we stand today, these promises often seem to be nothing more than a mirage, leaving our farmers grappling with the harsh realities of unfulfilled expectations and environmental setbacks.

The Government's pledge to revolutionise farming through the Environmental Land Management (ELM) scheme, a post-Brexit brainchild, was intended to replace the EU's subsidy system with a more environmentally conscious approach. This scheme, theoretically, would reward farmers for their contributions to environmental protection and food security.

Yet, the reality is starkly different.

The ELM's rollout has been marred by delays and inefficiencies, leaving farmers in the lurch. The Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI), which forms the backbone of this new system, has been particularly problematic. In 2022, a mere 224 farmers received payments under this scheme, and the 2023 rollout has been pushed back, further exacerbating the financial strain on our agricultural community.

Farmers like Sam Vincent and Emma Lee, who have shown a commitment to environmentally friendly farming practices, find themselves at a crossroads. Their applications to the Higher Tier Countryside Stewardship Scheme, which funds ambitious environmental projects, have been rejected due to a lack of capacity within Natural England.

This bottleneck is not just an administrative hiccup; it represents a systemic failure that undermines the very essence of the Government's green ambitions.

The decline in agreements under the UK's main environmental farming schemes is alarming. A 77 percent drop over the past decade is not just a number; it's a testament to the widening gap between policy and practice.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) appears to be struggling to deliver on its promise of a green transition in agriculture, raising serious questions about its capacity and commitment.

The Government's response, though optimistic, seems disconnected from the ground realities. While they claim an increase in Higher Tier Countryside Stewardship agreements, the voices of the farming community paint a different picture—one of struggle, frustration, and a sense of betrayal.

As we reflect on this situation, it's crucial to acknowledge the broader implications. The agricultural sector is pivotal in our fight against climate change and in achieving biodiversity targets. The current state of affairs not only impacts farmers but also jeopardizes our national environmental goals.

Ultimately, the Government must urgently bridge the gap between its green promises and the on-ground realities faced by our farmers.

It's time to move beyond rhetoric and implement effective, timely, and supportive measures that truly align with the environmental and economic needs of the UK's agricultural sector.

Our farmers, our environment, and our future depend on it!


bottom of page