A new study, published in the Journal of Chemical Ecology, investigates how female grape berry moths find their target amid a sea of other plants in the landscape.
The researchers originally hypothesised that grapes might have a unique profile of volatile compounds that the moths recognise, and perhaps other neighbouring plants have volatile organic compound profiles that deter moths.
They created a study design that gauged the attraction of female grape berry moths to volatile organic compounds emitted from grape vines, the moths’ natural host plant, as well as to nearby grey dogwood and apple trees.
“Chemical cues, signals, are used by almost all insects to locate resources in their habitat, such as mates or host plants,” said Charles Linn, a senior research associate at Cornell, now retired, and the senior author on the paper.
“Grape plants produce maybe hundreds of compounds, but the insects are really only detecting a subset with their antennae,” said Greg Loeb, professor of entomology at Cornell Agritech and a co-author of the paper.
Michael Wolfin, Ph.D. ’17, a postdoctoral researcher at Penn State, is the paper’s first author.
The researchers ran gas chromatography, electro-antennal detection and mass spectrometry analyses coupled with behavioural tests in a wind tunnel and identified 11 volatile organic compounds emitted by grapes that the moths detected. Though these compounds appear in particular ratios in grapes, they are common and are shared by most plants, including grey dogwood and apples.
When the study’s authors used the grape vine odours to lure the moths into traps, the method worked, but ineffectively.
In wind tunnel tests, the researchers found the moths flew upwind at the same rates toward both plant clippings and extracts of volatiles from grapes, dogwood or apples.
“The berry moth wasn’t showing clear evidence of discrimination based on these compounds” over long distances, Loeb said. “We suggest that maybe plant-eating arthropods are using these common volatiles to find the correct habitat, and then using other cues to zero in on where they are going to lay their eggs.”
“These results support a model that is in marked contrast to others in the literature and should provide a new hypothesis for future testing,” Linn said.
More study is needed to determine what cues the moths use to find berries. A preliminary study using artificial wax grapes showed that berry moths would not lay eggs on bare wax, but when a grape skin was laid over the wax, the females did lay eggs, suggesting there is something on the skin’s surface they recognise.
Though no deterring volatiles were found, the research offers clues for breeders to perhaps develop varieties with tweaked ratios of volatiles to throw insects off scent.
The study was funded by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
Source: Cornell University