Peers Urged To Publish EU Reset Impact Assessments As FPC Warns Of £300m Fresh Produce Bill
Peers have called on the Government to publish full impact assessments for its proposed UK-EU reset agreements, as the Fresh Produce Consortium warned that dynamic alignment on sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) rules could impose major new costs on Britain’s fresh produce supply chain.

According to The Grocer, members of the House of Lords European Affairs Committee said the Government should set out a separate economic assessment of the impact of dynamic alignment with EU rules under the proposed food and drink agreement, ahead of the UK-EU summit on 20 November.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham is expected to seek agreement on a new SPS deal with the EU, alongside wider discussions covering emissions trading and youth mobility. However, peers warned that the changes would amount to a “fundamental change” in the UK-EU relationship and could create significant new challenges for food and drink businesses.
For the Fresh Produce Consortium, the central concern remains the impact on imports from the Rest of the World, which play a vital role in keeping the UK supplied with affordable fresh fruit and vegetables all year round.
FPC has consistently argued that the UK must maintain its own science- and risk-based regime for non-EU produce and avoid importing unnecessary EU bureaucracy into supply chains that are already working effectively. The organisation has warned that fresh produce imported from outside the EU could face more than £300m a year in additional costs if new EU-style requirements and border checks are applied.
That matters because around 4 million tonnes of Rest of World fresh produce could be affected. FPC has previously highlighted that this volume is equivalent to around 50 billion portions of fruit and vegetables, underlining the potential implications not only for importers and retailers, but also for consumer choice, affordability and national healthy eating goals.
The Lords committee also questioned the Government’s headline claims for economic gain. While ministers estimate that the SPS agreement could increase GDP by up to £5.1bn by 2040, peers said those figures do not account for financial contributions, compliance costs for businesses that do not trade with the EU, or the wider opportunity costs of limiting future regulatory choices.
That concern mirrors FPC’s position that any agreement must be assessed not simply on headline trade facilitation claims, but on its full effect across all supply chains, especially those serving the UK from global origins. FPC argues that Rest of World supply complements, rather than competes with, UK and EU production, helping ensure continuity of supply and access to a diverse range of fresh produce.
Peers further warned that the SPS deal could have wider implications for farming and precision breeding, and said the Government should publish an assessment of how alignment with EU rules on plant protection products could affect farm incomes and future trade negotiations.
The committee also highlighted the broader constitutional and practical implications of dynamic alignment, warning that Parliament could face scrutiny of at least 780 pieces of in-scope EU law each year under the SPS agreement alone.
For FPC, the issue is clear: while reducing friction in UK-EU trade may sound attractive, the Government must not do so at the expense of efficient and highly compliant global fresh produce supply chains. The consortium has repeatedly stressed that the UK fresh produce sector already delivers around 99.5% border compliance and should not be saddled with self-imposed costs, delays and complexity that risk pushing up prices for consumers.
With the Brussels summit approaching, the growing pressure from peers adds to calls for the Government to spell out exactly who will bear the cost of any reset deal. For the fresh produce sector, FPC’s message remains that any new SPS framework must protect the resilience, affordability and diversity of the UK’s food supply, not undermine it.


Comments