PM’s “Win-Win” Risks a £300m Lose-Lose For Britain’s Shoppers, Warns Fresh Produce Industry
Shoppers face a bill of more than £300 million a year, nearly £6 million every week, and Britain’s food security is at risk unless the Prime Minister protects half of the UK’s fresh produce imports at Friday’s UK–EU summit in Brussels, the Fresh Produce Consortium (FPC) warns today.

As drafted, the deal would impose EU sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) rules, through EU SPS dynamic alignment, on around four million tonnes a year of fresh produce sourced from outside the EU and destined solely for UK consumers. These are the citrus, mangoes, blueberries, sweet potatoes and many more that keep British shelves full all year round: roughly 50 billion portions of fruit and vegetables.
Nigel Jenney, Chief Executive of the Fresh Produce Consortium, said: “A win-win that adds £300 million a year to the nation’s shopping bill is no win at all. The current proposals don’t solve the problem. They simply move the burden onto our trading partners beyond the EU, who are critical to feeding our nation, and the bill lands on hard-pressed UK shoppers.”
The win-win is already on the table
FPC’s established solution is a long-term exemption from EU SPS dynamic alignment for Rest of World fresh produce consumed only in the UK, keeping the UK’s science-based regime that already delivers 99.5% compliance across some 120,000 consignments a year.
• Shoppers win: no £300 million bill, and the choice and value they rely on.
• Food security wins: global supply keeps working alongside British growers, filling the gaps when UK and European seasons cannot.
• The EU wins: EU produce already enters Great Britain without plant health checks, and none of the goods imported solely for UK consumption can be re-exported to the EU. The EU is fully protected.
Kept in the dark
Days from the summit, industry has been told only that “some changes” at the non-EU border will be required. Under dynamic alignment, that is fundamentally untrue. FPC’s comparison of UK and EU inspection frequencies shows the two systems are diametrically opposed. The UK’s starts with the evidence and targets checks at genuine risk.
The EU’s starts with a protectionist rule, applying certification and checks to almost all non-EU fresh produce regardless of a supplier’s track record. And the UK would be bound to follow future EU rule changes without any vote on them.
Can the border cope?
FPC fears that border capacity and, critically, Defra and APHA resources are insufficient for highly perishable consignments arriving around the clock. Previous border changes brought late policy shifts, thin guidance and systems that failed, all at the food sector’s expense.
For fresh produce, delay means shorter shelf life, more waste and emptier shelves. Businesses that invested in border facilities at Government’s request, without grant funding, now face seeing that investment stranded.
Nigel Jenney added: “Britain is a small island with a big population, and Europe alone cannot feed this country. Our global supply network is a strategic strength, not a weakness. Yet we have been told almost nothing about what will change, or whether the border can cope. If Government gets this wrong, shoppers will feel it for years.
"The Prime Minister has pledged to champion consumers and to ‘pull every single lever’ to ease the cost of living. If he is to live up to that promise, he must make the right choice this week: protect the global supply chains that keep fresh, healthy food on our tables at prices families can afford, rather than load them with needless cost.”
The Government’s own evidence
Defra’s own survey, published on Friday, found food and drink SMEs want less paperwork (79%), lower trading costs (78%) and fewer border delays (71%). For Rest of World fresh produce, the deal as drafted delivers the opposite. The same day, a House of Lords committee reported that witnesses largely agreed dynamic alignment could cause difficulties in the UK’s wider trade relations, primarily through the SPS Agreement, with evidence it could conflict with CPTPP and the UK’s trade deals with Australia and New Zealand.
FPC’s six asks of Government
1. Secure the Rest of World exemption as a fundamental outcome of Friday’s summit.
2. No cost without benefit: no added cost and complexity for zero consumer value while households struggle with the cost of living.
3. End the silence: publish what will change at the non-EU border, and when.
4. Prove the border is ready before any change takes effect.
5. Compensate in full the businesses that invested in good faith at Government’s request.
6. Be honest before it’s too late: adopt industry’s proven solutions and meet the sector before any agreement is finalised.
Businesses can add their voice before Friday through the UK-EU Reset Industry Action Pack.


Comments